‘West Philippine Sea’ is fiction, and a dangerous one
PRESIDENT Ferdinand Marcos Jr.’s worst assertion in his recent State of the Nation Address was that the “West Philippines Sea is not fictional” (kathang-isip). He melodramatically, but in a jingoistic manner, claimed: “This is ours, and it will remain ours until our love for the Philippines is aflame.” Marcos is so blatantly wrong.
“WPS” is fiction, and I will stop writing forever if anybody can prove I am wrong. Worse, Marcos is maliciously tapping on Filipinos’ nationalist sentiments against another nation and ensuring US support to buttress his failing presidency. Emotional sentiments against other countries are not easy to reverse, making it extremely difficult for our country to resolve our territorial maritime disputes with China and Vietnam in the South China Sea.
It was the late President Benigno Aquino 3rd, the son of Marcos’ father’s archenemy, who demonstrated his utter ignorance of our territorial and maritime disputes in the South China Sea. Ironically, Marcos, in his SONA, announced to the world that he embraces the absurdity of this fiction invented by Aquino 3rd. Jedi master Obi-wan was certainly right when he rhetorically asked: “Who is more foolish? The fool or the fool who follows him?”
Aquino 3rd created the “West Philippine Sea” through his Administrative Order 29 of Sept. 5, 2012, which defined the “West Philippine Sea” (WPS) as the western side of our exclusive economic zone (200 nautical miles from the “baseline,” roughly the outermost land points of the archipelago). It includes the waters “around, within and adjacent to the Kalayaan Island Group (KIG) and Scarborough Shoal.”
For starters, for the KIG to be part of the WPS is no longer tenable: our arbitration suit against China ruled that the KIG is as illegal as China’s nine-dash line, and we committed to comply with it.
We lost Scarborough Shoal to the Chinese even earlier, in May 2012, and China Coast Guard vessels routinely patrol it and drive away foreign vessels at will, as it claims the area is part of Chinese territory. How can we include it as our WPS?
(more…)






